“The essence of this matter aptly can be captured as: ‘For now I ask no more than the justice of eating.’”- Judge S Potterill
SECTION27, Equal Education (Equal Education), two Limpopo School Governing Bodies and the Equal Education Law Centre (EELC) have secured a historic victory to feed millions of hungry learners, in a case against the Department of Basic Education (DBE) and eight MECs.
On Friday 17 July judgment was handed down in the North Gauteng High Court ordering the DBE to provide food to all qualifying learners immediately. “A more undignified scenario than starvation of a child is unimaginable. The morality of a society is gauged by how it treats its children. Interpreting the Bill of Rights promoting human dignity, equality and freedom can never allow for the hunger of a child…” said Judge Potterill.
In a hearing on 2 July part of the DBE’s argument held that they had not ‘refused’ the NSNP, yet based on research conducted by EE and SECTION27 they had continuously failed to do so.
The DBE also argued that the NSNP was not part of educational legislation despite a conditional grant being granted to the department for this exact purpose.
In her judgment however, Judge Potterill said that the Minister of Basic Education, Angie Motshekga, had a constitutional and statutory duty to ensure that the National School Nutrition Programme (NSNP) provides a daily meal to all qualifying learners. Judge Potterill said that by not doing this, the minister and basic education MECs were in breach of those constitutional and statutory duties.
The judgment further declared that “The Minister is ordered without delay to ensure that the NSNP is implemented in such a manner that it provides a daily meal to all qualifying learners, to ensure the proper exercise of the rights of learners to education and to enhance their learning capacity, whether they are attending school or studying away from school as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic.”
On the matter of Minister Motshekga saying that the department would not be able to roll out the NSNP to all learners, Judge Potterill, said that “The Minister’s does not justify why from 8 June 2020 it was reasonable not to roll out the NSNP to all the learners. It is common cause that the funding of the programme is not in issue. In the papers there is no averment that it is logistically impossible…The NSNP not being executed deprives indigent children of a basic right, food, and simply could not be justified.”
The judge went on to further issue a supervisory order stating
“The Minister is ordered within 10 days to file at this Court under oath, and provide to the applicants, a plan and programme which she will implement without delay so as to ensure that the MECs carry out without delay their duties referred to above, and which address the following matters:
- What steps she has taken to ensure that the MECs continue to provide food to all qualifying learners during the State of Disaster without delay;
- What further steps she will take in that regard;
- When she will take each such step.
- The Minister is ordered to file reports with this Court under oath, and provide copies to the applicants, every fifteen days from the date of this order until the order is discharged by this Court, setting out the steps she has taken to give effect to this order, when she took such steps, what the results of those steps have been, what further steps she will take, and when she will take each such step.”
Of the desperate and heartbreaking affidavits submitted by learners, parents, teachers and SGB members the judge said “The affidavits make it clear that hunger is not a problem, hunger is an obscenity”
In a joint statement released on Friday 17 July EE, EELC and SECTION27 said, “We welcome the judgment for its recognition that the constitutional rights to basic nutrition and basic education are inextricably linked, and celebrate this as a victory not only for over nine million learners, but for the millions of households whose food security has been gravely compromised due to the Covid-19 necessitated lockdown. For learners to receive meals at school will ease the strain on caregivers – many of whom have lost their income and are struggling to put food on the table.”
The NSNP was suspended on 13 March thrusting millions of learners into hunger as many of them relied on the school meal as their only meal of the day. SECTION27 and the Equal Education Law Centre (EELC) filed urgent papers in the North Gauteng High Court on Friday, 12 June 2020, in a desperate attempt to address the dire situation in poor schools where nine million learners are not receiving food at school as the Covid-19 lockdown put a stop to this.
“Hunger is not an issue of charity, but one of justice.” said Judge Potterill. DM/MC
Comments – share your knowledge and experience
Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or if you are already an Insider.